Guns to end guns: Concealed carry not for campus

By on February 17, 2016

By Kyeland Jackson–

Someone posted a petition to bring concealed carry to campus on a bulletin board in the library. Reading “Gun free zones don’t work” and “Universities choose to make you an easy target,” the petition asks readers to support bill HB 221, a state bill to allow citizens to carry concealed weapons on university campuses.

Concealed carry off campus is already allowed, with the bill simply extending current law. The purpose of the bill is to “defend ourselves as a community.” But exactly who are you defending?

Using the phrase “fight fire with fire” doesn’t work here. Firefighters don’t use fire to extinguish fire. The only practical use of the phrase is when fires will redirect another fire. Here the same can be assumed. Throwing more guns into a gun equation will only move that problem elsewhere.

The uniform crime report for Kentucky cited over 200 thousand serious crimes in 2014. In that data, handguns were used for over half of homicides. Weapons law violations barely increased by 2.24 percent, up 49 incidents from 2013. Out of 280 homicides, 61 were caused by an argument and 31 were cited as negligent killing. Only one was cited as a justifiable homicide. It was not cleared.

Property crimes outnumbered violent crimes by three to one. Bribery, on the other hand, increased by 595 percent.

U of L has more of a theft problem than a violent one. Larceny and theft made up half of the offenses on campus, while destruction of property followed with a close fourth of the total.

Which brings me back to the topic at hand for guns on campus, and my second worry: the people getting the guns.

It’s not all about what harm they can do to other people. There’s a threat to even themselves. Campus shootings and homicides are a threat, but the discussion over gun possession has neglected an important factor: suicides and murder-suicides.

A study by the Violence Policy Center found there were 1,382 murder-suicide deaths in the U.S. in 2011. Firearms made up 89 percent of those events.

The University of Utah’s Library of Medicine cited over 30 thousand deaths from firearms in the U.S. in 2010. Suicide made up more than half of that.

In 2012, the American Psychological Association found that 30 percent of college students thought about suicide. Eleven percent thought about seriously harming others.

Mixing a large population of students with guns, probability for depression and a national tendency for murder-suicide when guns are around is preparing us for trouble.

The purpose of this is not to say we should do nothing. Something should be done to curb the increase of campus shootings nationwide. Whether that be an armed and trained faculty, increased security presence or enhanced safety measures, options should be explored. For that I applaud the thought of concealed carry, because it comes down to people wanting to feel secure and safe. But this isn’t a viable solution for U of L, and likely not for campuses nationwide either.

I would like to say I’m so concerned about this petition because I’m a concerned citizen. That I don’t want to risk the unnecessary harm of others around me. But it’s probably because I’m selfish. Selfish and afraid.

I, as a black man, am afraid to have a campus dominated by citizens with guns.

I’ve been told of racial oppression, warned of the targeting and always told to be vigilant. It’s all scary stories until there is another race-involved shooting.

And while I try to accept my mortality, I can’t help but be afraid my decision to wear a leather jacket one night will be my, or another black man’s, last decision ever made.

Whether it’s fact or fear based, concealed carry weapons aren’t an end-all to campus shootings. It’s only redirecting another fire, and an assurance that I’ll be more wary and afraid in a classroom with my peers.

About Kyeland Jackson

Editor-in-Chief at The Louisville Cardinal.

8 Comments

  1. Eric

    February 17, 2016 at 4:24 pm

    I’m sure the bad guys will follow the campus rules…

    I’ll carry my gun regardless of the rules.

    You however are free to wait for the police, I’ll risk breaking the rules.

    • Ilya Chernyavskiy

      February 19, 2016 at 12:10 am

      Eric,

      A great positive mindset. While I can’t condone breaking rules and policy, it is good that you understand the importance of being able to defend yourself. We have a wonderful Facebook page where we post updates and stay in contact with each other (in addition to our member email list). Feel free to contact us.

      Ilya
      i0cher01@louisville.edu

  2. Ilya Chernyavskiy

    February 19, 2016 at 12:08 am

    This article is filled with misdirection and wrong use of numbers/statistics on guns and how they concern campus carry. The UofL Chapter for Students for Concealed Carry is more than happy to help clear up any concerns students, faculty, and staff have on the issue of campus carry and guns in general. It really isn’t all that scary, kind of silly to be afraid of honest citizens.

    Btw, I am the one that posted the petitions :) My email was on all of them, how come you didn’t ask me about the issue?

  3. Aaron Spalding

    February 19, 2016 at 12:52 am

    Cardinal. I find it funny you chose to run this article on the exact day UofL students were speaking before the house in favor of this very same bill. Even after we told you well in advance what we were doing. I’m sure you would have no problem publishing a fair and balanced response from another student. I’ll be sure to send it through the same channels I did for my service dog article.

  4. David M. Bennett

    February 19, 2016 at 10:43 am

    “A shoot-out is better than a massacre!”

  5. Hadley Hendrick

    February 21, 2017 at 12:35 pm

    I fully support this article and agree that guns have no place on our campus. Kyeland, thank you for your thoughtful response to this issue on campus and I sincerely hope this bill does not pass.

    • Eric

      December 12, 2017 at 2:58 pm

      Guns are already on Campus, you just don’t know it. Just like there are criminals, rapists, serial killers. Maybe you should just ban all bad guys, and leave self-defense and logic to people who know what they are talking about.

      The only thing you are accomplishing is preventing young women who can’t fight-off a large man, or the chance that a law abiding citizen stops a massacre. Most civilians that carry are extremely careful, we have to be, we don’t have the State to defend or cover-up our mistakes.

  6. Tyler Ault

    December 12, 2017 at 2:12 pm

    Why were none of the counter opinions to this article ever published or posted? It feels like the Cardinal is not allowing all the opinions of the students to be public; just the opinion of the Editor-in-Chief.

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *